Welcome to Carlo’s Pizza of Port Washington
At Carlo’s Pizza of Port Washington, pizza is more than just food; it’s a cherished tradition rooted in love and community. Located on Main Street, Carlo’s delivers classic Italian flavors with a warm, inviting ambiance reminiscent of traditional pizzerias. Each slice boasts a crisp, thin crust and generous toppings, earning rave reviews from loyal customers who declare it the best in town. With a menu featuring delightful salads, crispy appetizers, and comforting soups, dining here feels like a homecoming. The dedicated owners, Danny and Roberto, create a familial atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back for more—whether for a quick slice or a hearty meal to share.
-
109 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050 Hotline: (516) 944-9754
Welcome to Carlo’s Pizza of Port Washington, a cherished gem located at 109 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050. This establishment isn’t just a pizzeria; it’s a community cornerstone that has become synonymous with authentic Italian pizza and warm, inviting service. Since opening, Carlo’s has cultivated a loyal following, with locals and visitors alike returning for its renowned slices, flavorful pies, and hearty Italian dishes.
As you step into Carlo’s, you're welcomed by an ambiance that captures the essence of a traditional pizzeria. The charm of Formica benches and a nostalgic vibe makes it the perfect spot to enjoy an old-school slice. Their menu boasts a range of offerings designed to please every palate:
- Pizzas: Known for their paper-thin, crisp crusts and generous toppings. Best sellers include classic cheese and pepperoni options that leave diners craving more.
- Salads: Don’t miss Rita’s Salad, a refreshing mix of grilled chicken, cucumbers, and roasted peppers, or the Large Antipasto Salad featuring salami, provolone, and artichoke hearts.
- Appetizers: The hand-cut Zucchini Sticks and Buffalo Wings are crowd favorites, frequently highlighted in customer reviews.
- Soups: Crafted with care, the Minestrone and Pasta E Fagioli are hearty choices, perfect for warming up on cooler days.
What truly sets Carlo’s apart is the passion behind every dish. Many regulars, like Bryan J., rave about the “best pizza in Port Washington,” praising the prompt and courteous service that makes every visit special. Another loyal customer, Nicole V., shares her love for the spinach twists, calling them her party favorites. It’s this dedication to quality and consistency that brings the community together and makes Carlo’s a staple on the local dining scene.
Your visit would be incomplete without sampling their hero sandwiches or the famed Pasta Fagioli, which have both won over many hearts. Each dish embodies the rich flavors and traditions of Italian cuisine, made with fresh ingredients and a lot of love. Even customers like Crystal L. found joy in a late-night order, declaring that Carlo's pizza was incredible—even when it arrived a little cold!
For anyone in the mood for a genuinely delightful slice or a true Italian experience, Carlo’s Pizza of Port Washington promises to deliver. Whether dining in or grabbing a quick bite, each visit guarantees a slice of nostalgia paired with superb flavors. Carlo's Pizza is not merely a choice; it’s a beloved tradition that continues to draw in crowds eager to savor the sweetness of a well-crafted pizza.
I've been a big fan for years! I think they have the best pizza in Port Washington. The service is always prompt and courteous. The ambiance is very much like a traditional pizzeria. Every time I travel and then return to town, our first order is always Carlos delicious pizza. Always arrives quickly and feels like it is fresh out of the oven. Their hero's and pasta fagiole soup are the best. Definitely order from here!
Carlos is the absolute best ! Ordered 20 spinach twists for my party as it's my favorite food (from Carlos only) and it was a total hit none left! Not to mention it was last minute and they totally manages to get the job done and make my day! I have known the owners my whole life here in port and I'm so thankful to have their food and families like Danny and Roberto's in this community! It's also my go to regular slice! Love you guys!!!
Great place for a slice. Did not disappoint. Friendly staff and super fair prices. Highly recommend.
Always fantastic pizza. Long tradition of feeding Port Washington by the slice and the pie. Super service as well. Much love - JGD.
Excellent. Old school. Formica benches, classic style. Perfect paper thin, crisp, and well done regular slice. It's like when I was a kid in Queens. Absolute treasure.
Pretty solid pizza for NY! It did not disappoint. We got a large pizza, half cheese and half pepperoni. We ate the pizza at the restaurant which I recommend since it tastes best fresh. They were pretty big slices and the cheese was gooey but had enough of a crust to balance that out. Service was fine and the pizza came out in a reasonable time. It's our go-to when we want a quick bite in Port Washington!
While staying in the hospital I decided to order from a pizzeria nearby. I was researching for really good slices and this restaurant had great reviews for it! Unfortunately my food came cold & my Snapple wasn't cold but good thing the nurse was able to warm up my food for me. I never eat cold pizza but I decided to not warm up the pizza cause microwave pizza is gross and wow! I was blown away by how good the slice was and it wasn't even hot! The wings were good but I definitely thought to myself on how I should have 3 slices lol!
Visited for lunch on 11/15/22. First time here. Nice little local pizza joint. Pretty solid regular slice and the chicken cesar slice was awesome. Owner was a gentleman and the service was great. If you're in the neighborhood and in the mood for some no fuss pizza, I'd recommend stopping in.
Growing up in Brooklyn I ate damn good pizza. It was everywhere from L&B to Franks(RIP) to Delmars to Pizza Di Amore Lennys etc. In the Southern Brooklyn of my youth resplendent with Sicilian immigrants, good pizza was everywhere. Some of the newer slice joints succeed splendidly like Pauline G's Belluci SCarr to a lesser extent and soon to try Baby Luc's.. Carlo's is a perfect slice. It speaks loudly and tastes of a time honored recipe. Crispy crisp crust and lots of good olive oil. I don't eat a lot of pizza and this was my second this week. SCarr's was my first and Carlo's was better. It's that instant yum that cuts through everything and at $3 a slice it is a little slice of heaven.